In the past few years, my parents have become big gift givers, and the competing forces of gratitude and greed and then inadequacy and resentment have been at play in my mind ever since. Part of me is so grateful for their generosity but then also thinks it's over the top and sending the wrong message about the holidays to Ella, and then the other part of me says, "Screw it—just give me the huge J. Crew gift certificate." On top of that, there's the feeling of not being able to measure up, wondering if my well-intentioned gifts get overlooked for their lack of a soaring price tag.
Among my extended family, my mother is notorious and often scorned for giving extravagant, lavish gifts. Everyone sees her generosity as a means of flaunting her wealth (which is greater than the rest of the family but not extreme by any stretch) and, in turn, making everyone else feel inferior. Naturally, she resents and adamantly denies that her gift giving is anything other than pure of intention. She also resents that despite being demonized for giving so generously, many members of our family have taken advantage of it or come to expect and even demand it. I think she's just looking for eternal gratitude (no small request), but regardless of her intentions, it rarely works out the way she would like.
Before Christmas, Matt and I talked about how far we wanted to take Ella's gifts this year, and determined that we definitely have different ideas about how much is too much... Last year, I made a concerted effort to go light on gifts and encouraged our family to do the same. We spent very little on Ella—the most important gift consisted of a dowel and some rope for her precious trapeze. And, naturally, she was thrilled with everything she was given. In line with what she received, the three of us worked together to make gifts of homemade bath products for all the women on our list and her friends at school, and I think the process of making something and seeing the delight on peoples' faces really got through to Ella. She was totally into it.
By comparison, I was very lazy this year. Virtually nothing was handmade, and most of the gifts I gave felt relatively uninspired. Considering the past few months were probably some of the most hectic of my life, I'm cutting myself some slack. Still, I'm sad that I didn't exemplify, for Ella, the spirit of tradition and giving this season. We were downright skimpy with the holiday cheer, and it's killing me that this was likely one of the last few Christmases when she'll still believe in Santa. The magic is going to be over before she's had a chance to really experience it (the way I want her to anyway). So, what about presents?
Matt argued that Ella is a lot like he was a kid when it comes to her toys—she plays with them endlessly, appreciates things genuinely and somehow remembers the forgotten thing (usually the one that I managed to purge when she wasn't looking) within a day or two. She does seem to appreciate everything she owns, and even manages to remember who gave her what, referring to "the puzzle Imogen gave me" or "the sweater Grandma made for me."
Can you tell I'm trying to justify too many presents?
At first when people asked her what she wanted for Christmas this year, Ella answered, "Nothing." I was taken aback. She really couldn't think of anything, which is lovely in one way and in another points to the fact that she has everything under the sun. Then we stopped in to see Santa before we left for Hawaii, and when asked, she told him that she wants some stickers and a bike. Being that a plane ride was required to return home, Santa couldn't bring her a bike. A Razor scooter seemed like a good substitute, and I already knew she'd love it. She has also been coveting a cabbage patch kid, and the nostalgic kid in me can't resist giving her the thing I wanted most that Christmas so many, many years ago. So, we had a scooter and a helmet, a new doll, and a couple odds and ends for her stocking. I thought that was more than enough considering all the gifts she received from various relatives, including the mondo-wooden-kitchen from my mother (see above bit about lavish gift giving).
But then Matt got it in his head that Ella is ready to have music in her room. He is a hi-fi/speaker junkie, of the horns and tubes variety and if you know anyone like that (or him!), you'll believe me when I say, "He's crazy." So, seeing that my mom just sent him a new video iPod (with the 80GB drive no less--see what I mean?), he really, really wanted to give Ella his old, first generation iPod and old Altec speakers/recharger. But sheesh, that seemed like a lot to me.
When I was her age, Santa brought me my beloved Fisher Price record player, along with Kool & the Gang's "Celebration" and Olivia Newton John's "Let's Get Physical". It was a banner Christmas. We were living in Manhattan, Kansas, and I remember seeing it next to our fake tree on Christmas morning, in all it's tan and orange glory. I remember finding two cinder blocks with my mom, spraying them with the leftover silver paint we had used to decorate pine cones, and then using them to prop up a sheet of particle board that became my music table. I felt so grown up to be able to take out the albums and put them on my very own turntable.
But, but... An iPod seems so much bigger to me, and I thought maybe it was all about the price tag and the fact that I have some small conception of what goes into creating such a complex piece of equipment. It doesn't matter to me that it's old and probably not worth $30. It was still, at one time, a $250 piece of hi-tech equipment. Despite all my feelings about it, I recognized the practicality of Ella having such a compact system in her room, with no CDs to scratch or cases to lose. So, I reluctantly agreed.
Nothing could have prepared either of us for her reaction. Matt forgot to wrap it. So after Ella had unwrapped all the gifts under our tree he just picked up the iPod and told her it was her last present. He started to explain that it was a hand-me-down, and the only reason he was giving it to her was because it was very old, and he was getting a new one, and she takes such good care of her things, and she can be trusted to be responsible for something so important, and yadda yadda. But, in the midst of him telling her about it, she started shaking her head and saying no, tears welling up in her eyes. I was sitting on the floor nearby, and she ran to me, broke down sobbing and curled up in the fetal position on my lap. She didn't move for 20 minutes. We were stunned.
After much cajoling, we were able to determine that she understood how much responsibility it was to have something like that, and she just doesn't want it enough to take that on. Amazing. We both know how much she loves to listen to music and how excited she gets when we let her change the song and adjust the volume on any stereo. I guess we've been effective in our teaching of, "this is very, very delicate..." and maybe too(?) firm with her about taking care of her things
My mother recently told me that she would have spoiled me the same way she spoiled my brother (i.e., intensely), but that I wouldn't let her. I'd agree with that statement, but I don't know if I could have put it so concisely on my own. When I was born, my parents were struggling to make ends meet, and I'm sure that during my very early years they imparted some healthy values about needing and wanting and giving and receiving. By the time my brother came along, who, to be fair, is a very different character than me, my parents were better off financially, and my mom most certainly indulged him. A lot.
Ella's reaction to the iPod made me meditate on the power we wield over her value system. It seems so intense and so very delicate. We engineered her to have that response and yet couldn't anticipate, or maybe figure through, how she would react. In the big picture, Ella is a very, very privileged child, just as I was, but I hope that, just as my mom reminds me I did, she keeps telling us when we give her more than she can take.
What a lesson. I'm still not clear how to read it all.